Acne is a common and chronic skin condition that affects a significant portion of the population. While acne itself can be distressing, it can also result in scarring, with an estimated 80% of these scars being atrophic. Atrophic scars, which include ice pick, boxcar, and rolling scars, present a significant challenge to treat.
This blog post will explore the use of injectable dermal fillers for atrophic acne scarring. For a comprehensive overview, you can download our full paper on the subject.
Understanding Atrophic Scars
There are three primary types of atrophic acne scars:
- Ice pick scars are deep and narrow, with sharp edges and a V-shaped cross-section.
- Boxcar scars are wide and flat, with well-marked, demarcated edges.
- Rolling scars are the largest type, and can reach a diameter of 5 mm.
The Role of Dermal Fillers
While a combination of treatments is often recommended for the best results , injectable dermal fillers are emerging as a valuable option for atrophic acne scars. This is particularly true for rolling and shallow boxcar scars.
Injectable substances can be categorized into two main groups:
- Hyaluronic Acid (HA) fillers: These treatments are readily available and easy to administer, and they appear to have a good side effect profile. However, they are not long-lasting and create less collagen than other products.
- Collagen stimulators: This group includes substances like polylactic acid (PLLA), Calcium Hydroxyapatite (CaH), and polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA). These are often longer-lasting and may be better suited to treating these types of scars.
A Closer Look at Different Fillers:
- Hyaluronic Acid (HA): HA fillers are best reserved for shallow rolling or boxcar scars. Volumizing fillers with greater cross-linking provide more volume but are better injected deep into the dermis to avoid lumps. Less cross-linked fillers can be injected superficially but provide less lift.
- Calcium Hydroxyapatite (CaH): CaH is longer-lasting than HA filler and studies have shown good results in acne scars. Studies have found CaH to be helpful in rolled and boxcar scars but not in ice pick scars.
- Polylactic Acid (PLLA): PLLA has been shown to have clinical benefits for up to two years. It is effective in long-term improvement of rolling and shallower boxcar scars. It is not effective in ice pick scars.
- Polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA): Studies have found PMMA to be a safe product over multiple applications and to have good efficacy in the treatment of acne scars.
A Word on Best Practices
Atrophic acne scarring is challenging to treat and requires a combination of treatments to obtain the best results. Given the current research, rolling scars respond best to injectable treatments, followed by shallow boxcar scars. Longer-acting fillers like calcium hydroxyapatite, poly- D-lactic acid, and polymethyl acrylate are best suited for treating these scars. With correct techniques, these products appear to have minimal side effects and reasonable efficacy. However, current research is not yet adequate to determine the best practice.
Download the full paper on injectable dermal fillers for atrophic acne scarring to learn more.